Shiloh vs Smile — which is harder to read?

Shiloh (Lexile 890) is the harder read — 480L higher than Smile (Lexile 410). Lexile differential ≥150L typically means a 1-2 grade-level difference. Both are in the 3-5 grade band, though.

What grade level is Shiloh vs Smile?

Shiloh: 3-6 grade range. Smile: 4-8 grade range. Both assigned within the 3-5 band. Specific district and curriculum vary; see each book's page for the full assignment history.

Which is more commonly taught, Shiloh or Smile?

Both Shiloh and Smile are in the top-10 most-cited books on ReadingList.school across US school assignments and curricula. Each book's individual page (/book/shiloh, /book/smile) lists every tracked assignment with source citation, so you can see which has broader curriculum reach in your specific region.

Should I read Shiloh or Smile first?

If they're in the same school year, follow the syllabus order (usually chronological by publication or grouped by theme). If reading independently: start with the shorter or lower-Lexile title to build context, then move to the other. Both titles often appear together on AP / IB reading lists as paired study.

Comparison

Shiloh vs Smile

How Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor and Smile by Raina Telgemeiercompare on reading level, grade placement, curriculum overlap, and shared themes — derived from primary-source citations on each book’s ReadingList page.

Shiloh

Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Lexile: 890L
Grades: 3–6
Published: 1991
Pages: 160
Genre: Realistic Fiction

Smile

Raina Telgemeier

Lexile: 410L
Grades: 4–8
Published: 2010
Pages: 224
Genre: Middle Grade Graphic Novel

At a glance

Lexile differential: 480L (Shiloh: 890L · Smile: 410L)
Grade-range overlap: Grades 4–6
Year-of-publication gap: 19 years (1991 vs 2010)
Page-count gap: 64 pages (160 vs 224)
Shared curricula: 25 of 83
Shared themes: 0 of 9

Reading-level difference

The 480-point Lexile gap puts Shiloh roughly substantially more demanding than Smile. Lexile differences below 50L typically reflect equivalent decoding load (sentence length + word frequency); differences above 200L cross developmental reading-band boundaries. More on how Lexile measures work →

Curriculum overlap

Both books appear in 25 shared curriculum frameworks:

Themes

Only Shiloh

animal welfare · morality · family · rural life · courage

Only Smile

growing up · friendship · self-acceptance · humor

Get these books

Shiloh

Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Where to find this book

Buy on AmazonPrime · 1-click Listen free on Audible30-day trial

Audible: new members only · many assigned titles are included with the membership.

Other formats on Amazon: Kindle · Audiobook

As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you. Pricing, Prime, and trial terms shown on Amazon.

Smile

Raina Telgemeier

Where to find this book

Buy on AmazonPrime · 1-click Listen free on Audible30-day trial

Audible: new members only · many assigned titles are included with the membership.

Other formats on Amazon: Kindle · Audiobook

As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you. Pricing, Prime, and trial terms shown on Amazon.

Shiloh

Smile

At a glance

Reading-level difference

Curriculum overlap

Themes

Only Shiloh

Only Smile

Get these books

Where to find this book

Where to find this book

Related on ReadingList